Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 27, 2016

In the Spirit of Fraternal Encouragement: A Music Detox


John Cuddeback, a philosophy professor at Christendom College, has invited his Bacon From Acorns blog readers to join him in listening to only a select few "classical" music pieces for two weeks.   I think it is a grand idea!  It offers a reset of our emotions and an opportunity to get to know several beautiful pieces intimately.  Read his post linked above to get his list of recommended pieces, overflowing with musical antioxidants.

Mr. Cuddeback does not include any Gregorian chant because of its intended use as liturgical prayer, but here I must lovingly disagree.   Are we not to pray without ceasing?  And is not the home our domestic church?  I think it would add greatly to the efficaciousness of the "fast" to listen to one piece of chant every day for the two weeks, especially if you did it first thing in the morning to help set the tone for the rest of your day.  Aside from the graces to be gained,  it would also give our parasympathetic nervous systems, so overloaded with the stimuli of modern culture, a rest, as Gregorian chant appeals directly to the intellect, not the passions.

Need more inspiration?  Here are two things I read today that I found immensely edifying.

Twelve Latin Chants Every Catholic Should Know:  This is great for narrowing down the choices, and it gives a little background with each chant.  Well, actually I lied.  It didn't help me narrow the choices.  With each description I was sure that I would finally decide on THAT piece, only to read the next description and decide that it was THE ONE.  Maybe I shall start at the top of the list and listen to each piece for two weeks until I have absorbed each one into my being.

Feeding Our Children Liturgical Garbage:  Jeff Ostrowski, who holds a Bachelor's degree in Music Theory, explains in a short Views from the Choir Loft blog post why we should listen to the best music and provide it for our children.  He shares some stellar quotes, too.

Sunday, April 10, 2016

A Housewife's Education: Without the Encumbrance of Degrees



An inspiring excerpt from Solange Hertz's Searcher of Majesty:


Ancient monks called Mary "the philosophy of Christians," and spoke of "philosophari in Maria."  Obviously philosophy belongs to the housewife as tent-making belongs to St. Paul.  It's comprehensive.  It's cheap.  It requires absolutely no special equipment but wonder.  One has to study philosophy and invest in expensive books to be a philosophy professor, but not to be a philosopher.  A philosopher is just anyone who's willing to hit head on, with his head, the mystery in what everybody else takes for granted.
Really only housewives have time to grapple in their native habitat with such things as space, time, being, motion, birth, or growth, in order to classify properly why dishes break, or why yesterday can't be lived again, what's up, or just who is my five-year-old.  Whatever the housewife chooses to study at home, she is in the enviable position of being able to go after knowledge itself, without the encumbrance of degrees.  This isn't an inconsiderable advantage, being set free to proceed at her own rate, without grades or classroom, toward what she, and not somebody else, needs to know.
Here I would like to insert that later in the book, Mrs. Hertz talks about women and the cyclical nature of their hormones, which explains their need for stable lives at home, and how our culture demands instead that they run hither and yon.  (I wonder what Mrs. Hertz would have to say about American women now fighting in wars!)  She compares this to how dairy cows are treated, which may seem funny, but it is so true.  Dairy cows lead quiet lives of regularity at home, because if they can't their milk dries up.  This is true of women too, whether it's producing milk for the baby or the milk of human kindness or sharing "the milk" of their wisdom.  I have come in contact with so many young women whose health has collapsed because of how the unnatural stress of college affects their hormones.  

Mrs. Hertz continues:
A mother's knowledge can't be just a series of isolated facts to be tabulated later, like a research assistant's.  It must be coordinated and unified even beyond the power of philosophy to accomplish.  It must be super naturalized.  It must become wisdom.  Wisdom can take unto herself any amount of undigested facts and transfigure them, but in this world this happens only through suffering, through pondering them painfully and deeply in the heart.
Few mothers can take it.  Their college educations rarely become a part of them to that extent.  Ignorant women are the curse of the home, as great female educators like St. Madeline Sophie Barat and Mother Janet Erskine saw only too clearly.  Educated women, on the other hand, can hardly be made to stay home at all!  They can't waste themselves on a handful of children, and a world greedy for their skills agrees only to readily.  Female education today is little more than a way out of the house.
The supernatural education of the young, nevertheless, depends precisely on teachers who are able to "stay home" and transmit to them the painful fruits of their wisdom, the "true knowledge of the things that are."  Wisdom knows, says Scripture, "the disposition of the whole world, and the virtues of the elements, the beginning, and ending, and midst of our times, and alterations of their courses, and the changes of seasons, and the revolutions of the year, and the suppositions of the stars, and the natures of living creatures, and rage of wild beasts, the force of the winds, and reasonings of man, the diversities of plants, and the virtues of roots," for wisdom knows everything, keeps track of everything and has everything, like the good housewife she is (Wis. 7:17-20).

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Writing in the Margins: Plato's Apology

"I hope you won't be too slavish about the Plan of Graded Reading.  My advice is, reach in anywhere.  If what you look at doesn't interest you, put it down and try something else.  Everything in this set will interest you sooner or later.  I recommend browsing as the best method of locating the possible world you want first to explore." 

--Robert M. Hutchins,  "A Letter to the Reader", Gateway to the Great Books, Vol. 1

How eagerly and happily I read this advice!

Mr. Hutchins goes on to explain in the Introduction that the works in in the 10-volume Gateway to the Great Books "are outstanding creations of the human mind, but they are not of the same order as the works included in Great Books of the Western World.  They consist of stories, plays, essays, scientific papers, speeches, or letters, and in some cases they are relatively short selections from much larger works.  In contrast, Great Books of the Western World contains whole books or extensive collections of books."

In the appendices of Gateway, Vol. 1, four graded reading lists are provided starting with "Suggested Readings for the 7th and 8th Grades" and progressing through "Suggested Readings for College Freshmen and Sophomores".  Each level includes readings from the Gateway set and the Great Books set.  If I were still homeschooling, I would definitely choose this as the basis for my junior/senior high curriculum.

In The Great Conversation: The Substance of a Liberal Education, which is the first volume of the Great Books set, there is a suggested 10-year reading plan using only the Great Books set.  Number one on this list is Plato, with two selections--Apology, Crito.

Taking Mr. Hutchins' advice, I followed my interest and started right in on Plato, finishing his Apology, which is from Dialogues of Plato.  This is Socrates defending himself to the Athenians.  I enjoyed it immensely, especially the way he tells about his experience of doing good by informing others that they are not truly wise and how in this manner he gains more and more enemies.  Too funny!  The Athenians of his time do not seem to be any different than the Americans of my time:  If you tell people  that they don't know what they are talking about, they usually are not grateful.  On the other hand, I can't think of a contemporary counterpart to Socrates.  And there is the whole issue of scale.  Socrates went directly to individual Athenians to question them.  He was well and personally known.  We have celebrities, but in general, we don't know them well or personally.

I also identified with his description of himself as a gadfly, "given to the state by God; and the state is a great and noble steed who is tardy in his motions owing to his very size, and requires to be stirred into life.  I am that gadfly that God has attached to the state, and all day long and in all places am always fastening upon you, arousing and persuading and reproaching you.  You will not easily find another like me, and therefore I would advise you to spare me."  We have many gadflies today, so many that I think we get hypnotized by their buzzing and do nothing.  Again, though, these folks are not in the same league as Socrates.  In fact, the most popular ones seem to be the ones whom Socrates would have found wanting in wisdom.

I also followed Mr. Hutchins' advice about writing in the margins.  He said that you can't really make a book yours until you make notes alongside the text.  Only then are you really engaging in a conversation with the author.   So I penciled in a few things.  I didn't feel really comfortable doing it, but it occurred to me that this was one way to share more deeply with my husband, who will be reading with me.  That encouraged me.

Saturday, August 11, 2012

The Truth of Beauty and Our Health

I read an article yesterday called "The Truth of Beauty: Educating the Moral Imagination".  It was written by Benjamin G. Lockerd and gave me lots to think about.  Particularly,  I spent a great deal of time pondering this excerpt:

St. Thomas Aquinas similarly argued that beautiful things have integrity, an integration of separate parts, as well as proportion and harmony (which seems to me to be another word for integrity or wholeness, since harmony is a resolution of different elements). Aquinas also points out that the true experience of beauty is not only sensory but intellectual—that it is a kind of knowing. Perhaps he was the first to make this distinction between beauty, which has this cognitive element interfused with sensory experience, and simple physical pleasure, which is exclusively sensory. This is another way of saying that beauty has to do with truth, not just with entertainment. St. Thomas wisely admits, however, that the term “beauty” is difficult to define and has different senses when applied to different things.

What Christianity added to the ideas of the ancient philosophers on this topic was the assurance that God had created the universe in such a way that it was inherently meaningful. According to the Christian view, everything in the world is a creature of God and a reflection of one part of His infinite goodness. The universe itself is the ultimate work of art, exhibiting to an astonishing degree that integration of parts within the whole. Thus the beautiful orderliness of the world is itself a reflection of God and a proof of His existence.

This excerpt stood out for me because I had been thinking about how the brain is affected by seemingly unrelated parts of the body.  I related it to things I have been reading about circumcision and gut bacteria.  In the case of circumcision, I read about MRI results of a baby boy who was circumcised.  The tests were run before the circumcision, during it, and afterwards:  

A neurologist who saw the results postulated that the data indicated that circumcision affected most intensely the portions of the victim's brain associated with reasoning, perception and emotions. Follow up tests on the infant one day, one week and one month after the surgery indicated that the child's brain never returned to its baseline configuration. In other words, the evidence generated by this research indicated that the brain of the circumcised infant was permanently changed by the surgery.

In the case of the gut bacteria, I listened to a talk on NPR about research conducted on rats and probiotics.  A control group was fed the standard rat chow for a period of time, then the individual rats were each dropped into water.  Each rat chow rat swam for five minutes and then gave up.  Another group was fed a probiotic-laced broth.  When they were dropped into the bucket, they kept swimming and did not give up.  The scientists removed them from the water after seven minutes, I believe, still swimming vigorously.  Tests were done on both groups to determine the level of stress hormones that were released during the rats' time in the water.  The rat chow rats had high levels of stress.  The probiotic rats did not.  Their brains had released GABA, a relaxing neurotransmitter.  So then the scientists cut the vagus nerve on the probiotic rats and repeated the test.  They swam for five minutes and gave up and had high levels of stress hormones, just like the rat chow rats.  Of course, this research was on rats, not humans, but my own experience with healing the gut and taking probiotics and GABA leads me to believe the same would be true in humans.

Clearly, there is a wholeness, an integrity, to our bodies that has not been being considered by standard Western medicine.  We are wonderfully and fearfully made.  Our bodies are beautiful, in the image of our Creator, and we cannot know the truth of them without considering the body as a functioning whole.  Modern medicine is all about specialties--looking at our bodies as a jumble of parts.  That's why modern medicine has been such a failure.  It denies the beautiful and the true.  It denies God's role in our creation and deifies "Science" instead.  We need to recover a truly Catholic idea of medicine.  

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

The Strange, Beautiful Texture of Silence

It's funny how you read about an idea that makes a huge impact on you and then that same idea pops up in everything else you are reading.  That's what has happened to me about the subject of silence/meditation.  It's not that I was unfamiliar with the concept, it's just that I have a new depth of understanding of it because it is being presented to me from several different sources.

For years now I have been upset by the intrusion of electronic media into my daily life.  My first memory of being disturbed by it was at an aquarium in New Orleans.  I'm guessing this was in the early 90s.  We had to wait in long lines, and I was dismayed to find television sets hanging above our heads.  I did not want my thoughts to be directed against my will.  Now this electronic intrusion has progressed to the point of being attacked by commercials via the gas pump.

Here is a marvelous quote from The Chosen by Chaim Potok.  Danny Saunders, a college-age Hasidic Jew,  explains silence to his friend Reuven:

"You can listen to silence, Reuven.  I've begun to realize that you can listen to silence and learn from it.  It has a quality and a dimension all its own.  It talks to me sometimes.  I feel myself alive in it.  It talks.  And I can hear it. . .You have to want to listen to it, and then you can hear it.  It has a strange, beautiful texture.  It doesn't always talk.  Sometimes--sometimes it cries, and you can hear the pain of the world in it.  It hurts to listen to it then.  But you have to."

This idea is expanded in A Guide for the Perplexed by E. F. Schumacher.  I'll write about it next time.

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

The Factory Model in Home Life

How important is efficiency in a family's home life?

I've been thinking a lot about this since we attended a dinner theater at church way back on Laetare Sunday.  The play presented was Cheaper by the Dozen, and I really enjoyed it.  It made me laugh.  The father and mother in this biographical drama, set in the 1920s, were an engineer team with twelve children.  They helped factories become more efficient, and they applied these factory ideals to their family life.  For example, the father showed the children the most efficient way to to take a bath, and he installed record players in the bathrooms so that the children could listen to foreign language instruction while they were in there.  No time was to ever be wasted.  Great emphasis was put on testing and being able to skip a grade.   The parents obviously loved their children and wanted what was best for them, and there is an absolutely fabulous defense of the pro-life position. . .It's just. . .I don't know.  I felt like they saw their children as products to be manufactured rather than humans to be nurtured.  This had nothing to do with the number of children they had, just their way of parenting them.  My feeling was that every one in that family had to be busy at all times improving themselves or doing something productive as determined by the parents.  Maybe it's different in the book on which this play is based.

As a mother whose children are grown, I often do look back and wish that I had done a lot of things differently, but making efficiency and "measured" education top priorities of my family life are not on my list.  Pondering this, I asked my dear engineer husband what he had thought of the family life portrayed in the play.  He admitted that he liked the emphasis on efficiency and achievement.  He also said that he did not want to live that way.   Whew!

Emma and I discussed this issue as we cleaned the kitchen after breakfast one morning.  She was reading A Daughter of the Land, by Gene Stratton Porter, and she said a female character marries into a family that emphasizes work.  It is often made-up work, and there is never an end to it.  Eventually the young wife gets pregnant, becomes exhausted from the lack of leisure and dies in childbirth.  Later, I compared this in my mind with one of my grandmother's favorite stories.  She married at 15, and she and my grandfather lived with his parents in the early years of their marriage.  This was in the 1920s, just like the timeframe of Cheaper by the Dozen.  My grandmother said that she and her mother-in-law, Martha Rollo Somerset, would hurry through their daily chores so that when they were done, they could snatch up their cane poles and Catawba worms and light out for Bassett's Pond.  Clearly, the "work" had an end, and there was this wonderful leisure to be enjoyed together at the end of it, the memory of which was so dear to my grandmother that it brought a twinkle to her eyes and a smile to her lips, decades and decades later.  I think this leisure was truly an end in itself--a time to absorb nature and enjoy each other's companionship--not just a "break" so that they could do more work.

I do believe that scheduling and efficiency have a place in family life.  I just don't know exactly what prominence should be given them.  Probably if I had had more children, I would have been forced to figure it out.  All I know is, my attempts to give primary importance to these things have never lasted long, whether from my own lack of discipline or because I simply don't value them highly enough.  Probably it's both. 

Friday, February 12, 2010

Scientism and the Superhero

I grew up watching cartoons on Saturday mornings, and I was always puzzled by the recurring story line of some crackpot wanting to take over the world. I didn't get it. Why would anyone want to take over the world?

This morning, via Lew Rockwell, I found this essay by Joseph Sobran, Annoying Words.

These two paragraphs stood out:

"Nowadays, “democracy” is what Richard Weaver called a god-term. To be democratic is to be good, and whatever is good must be democratic. Why? Nobody explains. In fact, it’s rare to find a useful definition of democracy.

“Medieval,” by contrast, is a devil-word, the opposite of “modern.” Why is everything medieval assumed to be bad? Again, nobody explains. But St. Francis, St. Thomas Aquinas, and Dante Alighieri, to name but three, were medieval men. To hear some people, you’d think all men ever did in the Middle Ages was pray and torture each other by turns. In the enlightened twentieth century, on the other hand, there was much less prayer and much more torture as man learned to fly, drop bombs on cities, and congratulate himself on his humanitarian achievements (such as making abortion easily available). Homicide is certainly more efficient now than in the Dark Ages. We can be proud."

If I had read that quote last week I would have understood it, but I have a deeper understanding now, especially of what Sobran refers to as "the enlightened 20th century".

What changed? Emma and I are slowly reading The Abolition of Man: C. S. Lewis and the Case Against Scientism by Michael D. Aeschliman. We're about halfway through, and it has been difficult reading for us, as we have not read a lot of the books the author discusses--not even Lewis's Abolition of Man. Emma and I are just scullery maids, picking scraps off the china from a 7-course meal. Still, those scraps invigorated us. We're digesting two words that are helping us clarify our thoughts: scientism and sapientia.

In the chapter, "Scientism vs. Sapientia", Aeschliman discusses the contributions of Cardinal John Henry Newman, especially his Idea of a University. This quote from that section gives good context for both words:

"In Newman the voice of the great central tradition of metaphysical common sense speaks, the voice of Plato, of Aristotle, of St. John's Gospel, of Cicero and St. Augustine, of St. Thomas and Erasmus and Hooker and Johnson. It is a voice and an intelligence that discerns and defends the validity of the natural science, but which doggedly opposes the inappropriate application of their assumptions and methods and the excessive claims for their regulative status in life and curricula. These applications and claims constitute scientism, which Newman precisely defines as 'an evident deflection or exorbitance of science from its proper course,' As an individual's common sense integrates and relates the findings of the mind and the separate senses, so "illuminative reason'--sapientia--regulates and synthesizes the methods and findings of the separate analytical sciences. Sapientia is an exalted form of common sense."

What's missing from this otherwise good quote is the mention of scientism's shunning of any moral responsibility. That came earlier in the chapter quoted above, when Aeschliman said that Kierkegaard, "wrote ominously of the devaluing process brought about by increasing numbers of people who believe only in quantity and technique without referring them to any general value or subordinating them to any moral norm or end."

And this leads me back to the cartoons, which I now believe were exploring what happens when scientism triumphs over sapientia, as in Sobran's "enlightened 20th century". The cartoonists were wrong about the world needing Superman, though. Christ is the only superhero who can deliver us from the mad scientists.

I'm looking forward to finishing this book and reading it many more times, using it as a guide for further reading. Maybe then I can feast at the table of great ideas, rather than pick at scraps in the kitchen.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Fortitude, Part 1

From A Tour of the Summa, by Msgr. Paul J. Glenn, which, according to the editor, is "a complete, chapter-by-chapter restatement of St. Thomas' work, intended to expose readers to the totality of St. Thomas' thought, and yet be brief enough to fit into one volume."

This book was recommended to me by Fr. Stephen Zigrang. I have never read it all the way through. Instead, it seems to be one of those books that I am content to sample as the need arises, but when it does, it is so helpful. I read about "fortitude" this morning and thought it so appropriate to our times.

The explanation of fortitude is not divided into two parts in the book. That division is my own editing. There are six more statements. I first posted this with the intent of completing 7-12 tomorrow. I've re-thought that, though, and instead recommend that you buy the book. It's published by TAN and sells for $22.50. The link above will take you to the book on Amazon.


123. THE VIRTUE OF FORTITUDE

1. We speak of fortitude as a virtue. In another place we shall discuss the gift of the Holy Ghost which has the same name. Fortitude is the virtue which enables a person to withstand the greatest difficulties that block him from attaining his true goal.

2. It is the special business of fortitude to stand up to grave difficulties and dangers. Since it it has a special business, a special aim and purpose, it serves good in a special way, and is a special virtue. This means that fortitude is specifically distinct from other virtues, and is a clear-cut virtue on its own account.

3. Fortitude puts down the paralysis of fear that would keep a person from facing up to danger. On the other hand, it moderates daring or courage which, without it, might lead a man to wildly impulsive and ineffective action.

4. In strictest interpretation of its meaning, fortitude is the virtue of bravely facing the danger of death. A man capable of meeting with fortitude this greatest of dangers is not daunted by lesser perils.

5. Therefore, fortitude is a soldierly virtue which faces danger of death in defense of a just cause, whether in actual war, or in the warring we wage in daily life against the enemies of our soul and its salvation. Fortitude is the hero's virtue, the martyr's virtue; it faces death bravely in spite of inner fears. Fortitude strengthens the soldier in war; fortitude helps a man practice religion in the face of of derision and persecution; fortitude enables a person to care for the sick or to bury the dead in spite of the serious risk of deadly infection.

6. The chief act of fortitude is is that of enduring, of bearing up, of seeing the business through. It is not alone the virtue of coming to grips with danger; it is also the
holding on.